It is a timeless masterpiece that long resides in the hearts and minds of. Pacification is the more formal term for winning hearts and minds. A feature length documentary made between 1972 and 1974, it portrayed the vietnam war as it was still going on, but refused to offer an objective stance. In their minds and where theyre from, theres much more nobility and dignity in sacrificing yourself for somebody else time and time again. Troubled by three chance encounters with an african guy, albert hires a pair of existential investigators, vivian jaffe lily tomlin. Hearts and minds a must to avoid vietnam veterans of. The film hearts and minds by peter davis was made in 1974.
The editing, though often manipulative, seamlessly weaves actual footage with interviews, giving the film a. Rent hearts and minds 1974 on dvd and bluray dvd netflix. Why were still talking about, and watching, hearts and. Regular folks who just so happen to have cameras in front of them for extraordinary reasons.
Hearts and minds film the hearts and minds film initiative is the flagship program of serviam media. Hearts and minds is a 1974 american documentary film about the vietnam war directed by peter davis. A key theme is how attitudes of american racism and selfrighteous militarism helped create and prolong this bloody conflict. Another film that should be required viewing from this era is. The film also endeavors to give voice to the vietnamese people themselves as to how the war has affected them and their reasons why they fight the united states and other western powers while showing the basic humanity of the people that us propaganda tried to dismiss. Throughout the film davis interviews many people about their true opinions and views of the war and the united states. Staring jenna haze, aurora snow, ann marie rios and sunrise adams. This is a film that is more than an evenings entertainment. In the end, hearts and minds remains a flawed film that simply seems too onesided for its own good. Newsweek had a fawning interview in its april 6 issue with peter davis, the director and coproducer of the 1975 documentary, hearts and minds, on the occasion of its recent dvd reissue. Using a wealth of sourcesfrom interviews to newsreels to footage of the conflict and the upheaval it occasioned on the home frontdavis constructs a. Im far removed from the war i wasnt even born yet and can only view it from an early 21 st century perspective.
Responding to the camera following him across a broken, muddy plot of land where the. Jiro ishimaru, and others, the world is able to see the inside of north korea, exposing the country for what it truly is. Prans story was a magnet that pulled us through the film. Hearts and minds begins with footage on a village that is northwest of saigon in vietnam named hung dinh. Watching hearts and minds 35 years after its release its difficult seeing how the film worked when originally in theaters. Peter davis landmark documentary hearts and minds was completed at a very particular moment in the history of the vietnam war. The story of a marine grunt in the first battle of khe sanh april 1967 duration. A comparison of malay films produced in the 1950s in the chineseowned, singaporebased malay film industry with those produced in the kuala lumpurbased, governmentsupported malayan film unit mfu exposes many. Argument by irony in hearts and minds and fahrenheit 911.
Paradigm corepresented the film with protagonist pictures. The film had its world premiere at the 1974 cannes film festivalless than a year after the casechurch amendment ended direct u. Those who remember the 1975 documentary on vietnam, hearts and minds, could mistake this new book for the script of the film by peter davis. Anyone with an active interest in the vietnam war will want to take a. Daniel ellsberg hearts and minds is a 1974 documentary film directed by peter davis. Critics of this film argue that this film doesnt utilise hard political analysis. Henry golding drama monsoon acquired by strand releasing. Daniel ellsberg, who had released the pentagon papers in 1971, discusses his initial gungho attitude toward the war in vietnam. Usually you dont see a lot of formalism in a film but with hearts and minds i. Peter davis truly scrutinized the vietnam war in this film along with the involvement of the united states. In 1975, daniel ellsberg a temporary hero of the left because of his brave. It didnt follow the traditional documentary structure. Power is virtually the first word heard in peter daviss epic documentary, hearts and minds, and power, real and mythical, is what the film contemplates in as many tones and moods as you might. Hearts and minds is a 1974 american documentary film about the vietnam war directed by.
Hearts and minds 1974 letterboxd your life in film. Hearts and minds is a ucla thesis film about the psychological effects of war and addresses veterans returning from the war zone. When a film carries a title as heavy as hearts and minds, it is crucial not to overlook its importance in labeling the film and its significance to what happens within it. My problem in writing about hearts and minds is how to go about separating the films images which are sometimes heartbreakingly tragic. Rather director peter davis was vehemently anti the war and this is what his film reflects. The film also features vietnam war veteran and antiwar activist bobby muller, who later founded the vietnam veterans of america. Hearts and minds is a 1974 documentary film directed by peter davis it is a history of americas involvement in the vietnam war. When the issue of hearts and minds arises in the film, it is not only concerned. The knock against hearts and minds is that davis editorializes unfairly, and makes fools out of men like rostow and westmoreland, who submitted to interviews that become ambushes in the editing.
That film was fired by a pure, burning anger against a great injustice, and it had a dramatic center in the life and saga of dith pran, the cambodian who survived the occupation of his land and eventually lived to find freedom. The film is definitely set up differently than a hollywood film. This documentary opens up the psychic wound of a country and its citizensone we apparently still havent learned from, which is why this film still feels so vital. Hearts and minds is a powerful film that deals with the vietnam conflict and is also one of the very few films of this genre that looks at it from the viewpoint of its victims, the vietnamese people. However, the movie contains so much excellent material that it succeeds despite these problems. What i found instead was a film of such power and vitality, that it is just as moving now as when it was created, forty years ago.
The film however did seem very theatrical at first. Scenes from actual news footage is shown villages burned, dead bodies, and bloody injured soldiers as well as testimonials from american soldiers, some of whom are now paralyzed. On the 40th anniversary of hearts and minds, vogue. Its hard to deny this is truemichael moore, who considers the film among the greatest ever made, clearly took some pages from davis playbook. Its mission is to foster civic engagement, using the media arts as tools for youth leadership development, community education and outreach. However, the film does demonstrate how even though the years change numerically and the. This film recounts the history and attitudes of the opposing sides of the vietnam war using archival news footage as well as its own film and interviews.
Herring and ngo vinh long in the excellent and updated liner notes that accompany its reissue. And then it was shelved for a year because its original distributor, columbia, feared legal problems. Whichever way you look at it, there can be no denying the importance of hearts and minds. When the issue of hearts and minds arises in the film, it is not only concerned about the emotions towards the war at home, but also. Hearts and minds is a powerful indictment against the vietnam war. But the human faces, so devastated and brutalized by experiences they cant quite describe, tell the real story of hearts and minds. Hearts and minds is raising funds for postwar veteran awareness. Because of the nature of the conflict, policymakers usually reduced the vietnamese to targets in the war of attrition or unworthy allies, not human beings. Hearts and minds, a film study of power the new york times. Parents need to know that hearts and minds is an intense 1974 academyaward winning documentary about the vietnam war. Davis constructs the film in such a way that it plays as high tragedy rather than reportage. Final film critique 2 final film critique introduction the wizard of oz 1939 is a film that many even to this day have watched and can remember quite vividly thanks to its mise en scene and techniques used. Hearts and minds, a sentimental and intellectual film as its title suggests.
The film is a searing indictment of the united states and its presence in vietnam, depicting the ghastly toll of pain and suffering inflicted on the vietnamese people by the american armed forces. First they bomb as much as they please, then they film. Here is a documentary about vietnam that doesnt really level with us on a. So i approached hearts and minds warily, fully expecting to be treated to a didactic sermon. Using actual footage and interviews, hearts and minds makes the viewer question why america was involved in the war at all. Hearts and minds a grunts life episode 2 half o sode duration.
Without any type of introduction the film starts off in this setting and leaves its viewer unexpectant of what is to come. It is a history of americas involvement in the vietnam war. Its a nearimpossible feat to capture the hearts and minds of moviegoers when youre not a bigname star. Russells protagonist is albert jason schwartzman, a frustrated activistpoet and the founder of open spaces, a coalition dedicated to curbing suburban sprawl. A key theme is how attitudes of american racism and selfrighteous militarism helped create and prolong. The urgency of hearts and minds, its anger and its articulation, its insistence that effects of war be visible, and its cogent analysis of connections among politics, media, and.
The award winning documentary, hearts and minds, portrays the attitudes of the opposing sides in the vietnam war. Hearts and minds takes on the utter failure of five consecutive presidential administrations to win over either vietnamese or american hearts and minds. A powerful, unflinching exploration of the vietnam war, with firstperson stories from both sides of the conflict, hearts and minds still hits the. How to balance the genres need for lengthy sex scenes with the serious fans interest in a narrative character connection to the performers. Rent hearts and minds 1974 starring georges bidault and clark clifford on dvd and bluray. Throughout the film, you see various conversations with both a. We like to think that the people that capture our hearts and minds as subjects in documentary films are just like us. A startling and courageous film, peter daviss landmark 1974 documentary hearts and minds unflinchingly confronted the united states involvement in vietnam at the height of the controversy that surrounded it. The films title is based on a quote from president lyndon b. In ishimarus documentary, the film begins with ishimaru demonstrating to the viewer how he conducts his job of smuggling video footage out of the country.
55 533 894 853 1453 538 638 478 1013 1105 162 401 1278 247 762 62 351 420 893 814 335 751 887 869 656 802 901 509 226 757 1443 1089 191 112 999 1251 174